Skip to content
I Hate the Phrase "Legitimate Concerns"

I Hate the Phrase "Legitimate Concerns"

October 16, 2026

“We have legitimate concerns”.

I hate that phrase.

Thirty years ago, you’d only hear it as part of a dry discussion with lawyers or perhaps during discussions between unions and management.

But at some point it was hijacked by the far right to make their bigotry seem acceptable.

Yes, I used the word bigotry. I’m not going to mince my words - most “legitimate concerns” are simply bigotry.

Scared of brown people? Non-straight people? Or someone with a different religion? They’re “legitimate concerns”.

Yet for the same people opinions they disagree with are never legitimate concerns. Concerned immigrants may feel unwelcome? That the cost of living keeps rising faster than wages? Or about climate change? Well those things are most likely just woke frippery, and can’t possibly be legitimate concerns.

What really annoys me about it is that it’s such a stupidly effective phrase.

Ask yourself this - have you ever held a concern that wasn’t legitimate to you whilst you held it?

A concern is a worry or something you have anxiety about. Which means that they are always legitimate to you whilst you have them.

That does not mean that they should be legitimate for everyone else. Or even anyone else.

It’s also why the phrase “has an illegitimate concern” feels vaguely wrong, in the same way “the red blue” or “the square triangle “ feels wrong.

If someone wakes up tomorrow worried that the King of the Mole Men is conspiring with the squirrels to steal the road markings from the Forth Bridge, that concern is legitimate for them.

They’re plainly nuts, but it’s still legitimate for them.

What’s important for everyone else is that if they weren’t concerned, it would merely be an idea or a notion.

You can’t really have a concern that isn’t legitimate or justified for you at that time. That’s the nature of concerns.

We entertain other people’s concerns because it is an anxiety, and we do so out of basic decency and civility.

But as a society we are not obliged to share bigoted concerns. We should not blindly take the personal legitimacy of a bigotry and make it everyone’s bigotry.

Yet that is precisely what the far right attempts to do with the phrase “legitimate concern”. They attempt to clothe the bigotry in, well, legitimacy.

They are attempting to make it harder to criticise, harder to dismiss.

And I’m sick of it.

It’s well past time to stop them claiming legitimacy for their bigotry.

Last updated on