Skip to content
Windows Needs a Philosophy, Not Features

Windows Needs a Philosophy, Not Features

August 17, 2025
I wrote this in response to this article at the Register entitled “Microsoft keeps adding stuff into Windows we don’t want – here’s what we actually need”, but it rapidly became too long for a comment so I decided to drop it off here.

Windows is, for the most part, feature-complete. Small things could be added, but by this stage it’s got almost everything we want in it. Gone are the days when a computer needed Norton Utilities or PC Tools to be complete., the hardware and software has long since entered the realms of being a reliable commodity.

At a fundamental level, I want an operating system to do three things:

  1. Silently enable me to do things
  2. Serve me well when I ask it to
  3. Get out of my way so that I can work.

Silently enable me to do things

This is actually something Microsoft have historically been excellent at. We should give credit where credit is due, they’ve always been excellent at giving developers new APIs so that their operating system can do what you, as a user, want to do.

Examples of this include working with Apple to give us TrueType so we’d have something better than bitmap fonts, or giving us TAPI in Windows 95 so we’d have easy use of modems/faxes/ISDN, or APIs like the DirectAudio/Direct3D family which give high performance audio/video services.

We may mock the old Ballmer “developers” video, but that was part of a philosophy that saw Microsoft working hard to offer a platform that made it easier to do things. They do this well, and we should acknowledge that.

Serve me well when I ask it to

Windows has steadily gotten worse at this over the years. By this I mean that when I want to do something, it should be clear and obvious how I do it.

The decline started with Windows 8, and now we have this oddly confused mix of a Settings app (which I can only have one instance of, for no good reason) and the old configuration methods. I actually like the Settings app - or at least its integration into the Start Menu which makes searching for settings quick and easy - but the fact it’s incomplete after so many years is inexcusable.

The Settings app should not be the default configuration method until it’s ready, it should ship as an alternative until then. Don’t try to change the working paradigm to one that’s not actually complete.

And that’s the problem. It’s not that Windows isn’t doing things when I ask it to, it’s more that it’s not doing them terribly well.

And then there’s Windows trying to serve me when I didn’t ask it to. Why does Microsoft keep trying to push Edge at me? Ask me once, at most, and then go away.

The Edge Onboarding is an excellent example of how they’ve lost their way - if you accidentally launched Chrome or Firefox for the first time, you can easily close them. Edge has a full screen screen wizard with three or four stages and it’s desperate for you to click through before it will finally relent and let you close it.

It feels like they have loads of different teams trying to do things all slightly differently. Probably because they do. And that’s not good for Windows.

Get out of my way so that I can work

I don’t start a PC so that I can admire Windows. I start it so that I can do something. So just let me do that.

This is intertwined with the second point, yet it’s worth separating them so that each can be explored.

Just get out of my way. Don’t prompt me for things.

I haven’t responded to notifications for my email client for a while? Well maybe that’s because I simply make a mental note to switch to my emails when I’ve finished what I’m doing.

Only a crack-addicted squirrel with ADHD could live by interacting with every notification immediately. Perhaps for many of us a notification is just that - a notification. Make it easy for us to mute them when we’re reading them, but stop bugging me with notifications giving suggestions about my notifications!

Then there’s things like wanting me to have a Microsoft account, or use OneDrive. I get it - corporate synergy and all that boardroom bollocks - but if people want it, they’ll find it.

I remember a time when new features like this were made exciting or valuable, and we sought them out. Folks that were excited would find the feature, those that didn’t need it could work in peace. It was a civilised time. I miss it.

Please give me a Windows which allows me to launch a program and then just do some work.

A poor analogy

I’ve only ever done true fine dining once - the kind of dining where the bill is significant, and that’s just the wine. I’m not a rich person, so the whole experience was new to me. I noticed was that the staff were always there in the background, still yet attentive. If your glass was empty, the bottle low, or the course had finished, then they swept discreetly into action. If you wanted something, a mere look in their direction was enough to get a response. This allowed me to focus on enjoying the meal with my companions.

The staff did not hover around asking if I would like to sign up for a loyalty card, or perhaps read the menu at an affiliated resteraunt in case I’d like to go there in future. I’m sure that many executives would think that’s a missed opportunity, but fortunately the resteraunt understood why people go to that resteraunt and passed up those opportunities.

Microsoft needs to learn from that. Enable me to have a great experience, serve me when I ask you to, and otherwise let me focus on what I came here to do.

Closing notes

I’m sure Microsoft have a philosophy for Windows. But it’s probably a technical one, to do with enabling developers and preserving backwards compatibility.

They need to go further, and have a philosophy on how Windows will interact with us - and how we will interact with it.

Until then, Windows will continue to feel like a mess.

Last updated on