The Old Man of Huy wrote recently about whisky ratings, and I got mentioned.
I thought that this was a good time to talk about how I rate whisky.
The basics, first of all - I rate out of 5. And I use half points. Some people don't like that. That's fine - they can use their own rating system! :-)
I use 2.5 as "average", and try to arrange my ratings around that.
0 is technically "no rating". I try not to regard 0 as a usable part of the scale, but more way of recording that I'm not capable of categorising this whisky, and wouldn't want to. It does usually translate into "undrinkable", but might not always do so... If I could only nose the whisky due to medication and someone forced me to give a rating, it would have to be 0 even if I liked the nose!
I want two things from my ratings system. I want it to be easy, and I want it to be useful.
Let's look at easy first.